In one case, if he acknowledges he is the killer of his wife and indirectly his children because he was away so long and often he never noticed his wifes depression, he is the monster, but he can continue to live here on the island in peace, since he will accept the lobotomy. This film ends with a massive plot twist that has resulted in debates on what happens in the last scene. In shutter island, director martin scorsese has created a divinely dark and devious brain tease of a movie in the best noir tradition with its smarter than youd think cops, their tougher. What surprises me is that the movie has already come and gone in theatres without a huge amount of fanfare. So yes, im bias to shutter island because i prefer the story to the wolf of wall street however, the wolf of wall street is an incredible film as well. Martin scorsese and leonardo dicaprio team up for a fourth time for this adaptation of shutter island, a novel by dennis lehane mystic river. Feb 19, 2010 in shutter island, director martin scorsese has created a divinely dark and devious brain tease of a movie in the best noir tradition with its smarter than youd think cops, their tougher. Shutter island by dennis lehane goodreads share book.
Mar 02, 2012 martin scorsese and leonardo dicaprio team up for a fourth time for this adaptation of shutter island, a novel by dennis lehane mystic river. In the book, the code found in rachels room was longer and more complicated, and. So yesterday my lovefilm bluray arrived and, guess what. Apr 15, 2003 i read this book for my hometown book club. Surprisingly, i have never heard of shutter island, but now after reading this book i will have to check out the movie too.
Think about how sixth sense becomes a different movie on second viewing, but its somehow richer when you know how it ends. Shutter island is based on the 2003 thriller from dennis lehane, the author of mystic river filmed by clint eastwood and gone baby gone filmed by. Find books like shutter island from the worlds largest community of readers. This post contains spoilers for both the book and film versions of shutter island. Why shutter island is better than the wolf of wall street. I also read mystic river by the same author, dennis lehane. Otherwise, better to watch the movie then the book.
Gripping, from the first page to the last, the novel revolves around u. Even after reading it i feel it could have been but there were soooo many twists and turns i couldnt keep up. Expect a more inyourface warning immediately preceding the major shutter. Shutter island, by dennis lehane william morrow, 2003. New face of suspense and thriller is shown throughout the movie.
There is no mystery, however, about how good this book is. If you love to read books, you can go for it first. Jun 27, 2012 this post contains spoilers for both the book and film versions of shutter island. Dennis lehane talks about the dream that led to the book, seeing taxi driver at 10, and why hes done writing about violence against children.
What is the meaning of teddys last dialogue in shutter island. Marshal teddy daniels and his new partner, chuck aule, have come to shutter island, home of ashecliffe hospital for the criminally insane, to investigate the disappearance of a patient. In dennis lehane famous thriller was turned into a movie by martin scorsese. Buy shutter island media tiein by lehane, dennis isbn.
I watched the movie first, then read the book expecting big differences. Mar 01, 2010 the book denis lehanes shutter island fuses several different genres into a single work. Feb 21, 2020 while shutter island did not go on to have the awards success that the director and actors other projects did, it has continued to endure over the last 10 years because its blindside of a. Supersummary, a modern alternative to sparknotes and cliffsnotes, offers highquality study guides for challenging works of literature. For example, the book gives more detail about teddys upbringing, explaining that his father was a fisherman who died on the ocean and that teddy has always had a problem with seasickness, which provides insight into teddys illness on the ferry to shutter island. Shutter island is a contemporary motion picture version of a stylish hollywood crime drama. If your a movie goer who looks for more in a movie than you might like shutter island better. Spoiler alert the following spills the beans about shutter island. D ennis lehanes shutter island is a psychological thriller.
The audio book edition of shutter island is exceptional. Teddy wakes up to the reality that he is actually andrew laeddis, though he is warned by dr. Knowing this will completely change your experience in seeing the film or reading the book. Lehane has said he sought to write a novel that would be a homage to gothic settings, b movies, and pulp. The book was fantastic and ill just be disappointed in the movie version. Shutter island author dennis lehane gives his read on the. Marshals arrive on the island, now a hospital for the criminally insane, to investigate the disappearance of a patient. Read in less than a day, theres now no way i can go see the movie. In america, more than 40,000 patients were lobotomised over a 30year period. Shutter by courtney alameda is a thrilling horror story laced with an irresistible romance.
I saw shutter island last night on netflix, i enjoyed it. But that doesnt mean that shutter island is not home to a bunch of psychiatrists with military affiliations who conduct experiments on the patients. The film was directed by the legendary scorsese and adapted from a novel by dennis lehane mystic river, gone baby gone. Which movie is better, inception or shutter island. That is the only advantage of this over the dvd special edition release, which was loaded with behind the scenes bits. Shutter island is a 2010 american neonoir psychological thriller film directed by martin scorsese and written by laeta kalogridis, based on dennis lehanes 2003 novel of the same name. Inception got all the acclaim, but scorseses shutter island is tremendous and the better film. Marshal teddy daniels and his partner chuck aule, both of whom arrive at shutter island to investigate the sudden and mysterious disappearance of a patient. While shutter island did not go on to have the awards success that the director and actors other projects did, it has continued to endure over the last 10 years because its blindside of a. Sheehan that he has regressed into his fantasy world before. I was hoping for this book to be much better than it was.
He described the novel as a hybrid of the works of the bronte sisters and the 1956 film invasion of the body snatchers. Shutter island summary and study guide supersummary. Should i read the book shutter island, or watch the film. Martin scorsese interview for shutter island martin scorsese turned to film not long after embarking on a path to the priesthood, and his lifetimes work has been shaped by the passion and. While scorsese is very good at creating strong images and exploring powerful characters. And at its heart, shutter island seems to be peering into the nature of the human psyche. Martin scorsese interview for shutter island telegraph. Now pursued as a renegade agent by her monsterhunting father, leonard helsing, she must track and destroy an entity more powerful than anything shes faced before. Lehane is a master at creating palpable tension between the covers of a book, and nowhere is that more evident than in shutter island. Since i heard the movie was good, and the book is always better than the movie, i dug up my copy of shutter island. In the book, the ending is pretty much the same, with andrew remembering who he is, and ending the book on the. The book denis lehanes shutter island fuses several different genres into a single work.
You cant dig out the truth and kill laetis at the same time. Sep 08, 2010 so yesterday my lovefilm bluray arrived and, guess what. Multiple murderess rachel solando is loose somewhere on this remote and barren island. This bluray edition simply offers the movie in better clarity than dvd. The movie was very good but the book was even better due to more details. The film opens in 1954 as world war ii veteran and. Towards the end of the book maybe 23 or 34 of the way through, maybe someone with a better memory can help me out with the exact moment we find out that teddy is. Dennis lehanes shutter island is a psychological thriller. That is why we get the patient with the frankenstein stitches across his. May 21, 2017 here are my thoughts on the book and movie shutter island. Differences between shutter island book vs movie page 1. Separating fact from fiction the history of psychology is dissected and distorted in shutter island. Shutter island has once been described by the writer as a mix of invasion of. That is the only advantage of this over the dvd special edition release, which was loaded with behindthescenes bits.
Shutter island is a place where the criminally insane are kept. Jun 16, 2010 the ending of shutter island seems ambiguous to many people, but again, to me it was pretty clearcut. In conclusion, the way dennis lehane wrote shutter island was better at portraying teddy daniels than the way martin scorsese directed shutter island because of the significant character trait differences, the character development, and because of how the island actually looked. Both cases are teddy, himself, and he lives this duality. Why shutter island is the better film as most of you know, im a sucker for a good psychological thriller and shutter island is a terrific example of a modern classic of the genre. Shutter island has once been described by the writer as a mix of invasion of the body snatchers and the work of the. Nov 02, 2017 if you love to read books, you can go for it first. Also these two movies have two different directors, do you like christopher nolans work director of inception, dark knight or martin scorseses films director of shutter island, cape fear.
Might as well get that out of the way from the outset. Ive tried to avoid them as much as possible, but read with caution. I ve tried to avoid them as much as possible, but read with. The ending of shutter island seems ambiguous to many people, but again, to me it was pretty clearcut. Indicating that he hasnt relapsed, but cant live with the truth that he killed his wife. Which is absolutely necessary to understanding the forthcoming deconstruction of the story in order to expose its inherent story architecture.
The director martin scorsese and the writer laeta kalogridis base the film on dennis lehanes 2003 bestselling novel. Dicaprios performance is shutter island is much stronger and it leaves us with one of the greatest questions ever in a movie with its final scene. May 17, 2010 i also read mystic river by the same author, dennis lehane. This 59page guide for shutter island by dennis lehane includes detailed chapter summaries and analysis covering 25 chapters, as well as several more indepth sections of expertwritten literary analysis. Shutter island 2010 frequently asked questions imdb. Here are my thoughts on the book and movie shutter island. Heres where dennis lehanes source material for shutter island pulls a fast one. Marshal edward teddy daniels, who is investigating a psychiatric facility on shutter island after one of the patients goes. During that era, severe mental disturbances were often dealt with physically. Books similar to shutter island goodreads share book. Nov 11, 2015 why shutter island is the better film as most of you know, im a sucker for a good psychological thriller and shutter island is a terrific example of a modern classic of the genre.
Shutter islands ending explained david cox film the. Shutter island is a novel by american writer dennis lehane, published by harper collins in april 2003. Shutter island is a greatlooking, highly stylized, very intense thriller in the vein of martin scorseses earlier cape fear 1991. The book is often better than the movie and this might be the case with shutter island however im finding that hard to believe. And, although both movie and book have a surprising ending, it actually adds to the experience rather than detracting from it when you already know the surprise. Hardboiled detective fiction meets a paranoid, cold war suspense thriller with late 60s scifi thrown in for good measure. Goodreads members who liked shutter island also liked. Daniels, weighed down with his own baggage, has his own reasons for wanting to get to the island.
1125 1272 194 245 528 976 9 455 812 668 8 1148 1461 470 1009 194 171 704 1566 74 36 1377 1397 229 1264 1081 568 1465 137